Home » Latest » TRENDING NOW » How the Thunder failed to win a title after drafting three MVPs in a row

How the Thunder failed to win a title after drafting three MVPs in a row

6

50 0 TRENDING NOW

8.4

SaveSavedRemoved 3

Three MVPs, one roster, zero rings — that’s the Thunder’s story.

Before he was chasing rings in Miami and Golden State, LeBron James had to get through a Thunder team that, on paper, should never have lost a championship. Oklahoma City drafted three future MVPs in three straight years and still walked away from the 2010s with nothing to show for it. This video breaks down exactly how that happened.

• Sam Presti drafted Kevin Durant (2007, No. 2), Russell Westbrook (2008, No. 4), and James Harden (2009, No. 3) in consecutive years, giving OKC three future MVPs on one roster.
• The Thunder reached the 2012 NBA Finals, won Game 1 against the Miami Heat, then lost four straight games to fall 4-1.
• Facing the new luxury tax under the 2011 CBA, Presti traded Harden to Houston in October 2012 after the sides couldn’t close a $4.5–6 million gap on an extension; Harden immediately became an MVP-caliber scorer for the Rockets.

The Draft Haul No Franchise Has Matched

What Presti pulled off between 2007 and 2009 still has no real comparison in league history. Durant went No. 2 in 2007, Westbrook went No. 4 in 2008, and Harden went No. 3 in 2009 — three top-four picks in three straight drafts, all of whom would eventually win MVP. Add in Serge Ibaka as the defensive anchor up front, and Oklahoma City had a young core that looked built to win multiple titles before any of them turned 25.

The rise was fast. OKC broke through with a trip to the 2011 Western Conference Finals, then took the next step in 2012, winning the West and advancing to face LeBron James, Dwyane Wade, and Chris Bosh in the Finals.

Game 1 and the Collapse That Followed

The Thunder actually stole Game 1 in Miami, giving them a real shot at the franchise’s first title of the OKC era. Then it fell apart. Miami won the next four games in a row to close out the series 4-1, and the Heat’s championship window — the one that would produce two more rings — opened at OKC’s expense.

Harden went from Sixth Man of the Year in OKC to an MVP-level No. 1 option in Houston almost overnight.

That Finals loss turned out to be the closest the Durant-Westbrook-Harden core ever got to a ring together.

The Harden Trade and the Tax Bill

The break-up started with money. Under the 2011 collective bargaining agreement’s stiffer luxury tax, keeping all three max-level talents plus Ibaka became financially untenable for Presti’s front office. Negotiations with Harden stalled over what amounted to a $4.5 million to $6 million gap on an extension, and in October 2012, OKC traded him to the Houston Rockets.

The return — Kevin Martin, Jeremy Lamb, and draft picks that eventually became Steven Adams and Mitch McGary — gave the Thunder useful pieces, but nothing close to what they gave up. Harden didn’t just replace his production elsewhere; he leveled up into a top-tier MVP candidate as Houston’s primary option, while OKC never got back to the Finals without him.

Injuries, the 3-1 Collapse, and Durant’s Exit

Even without Harden, the Thunder kept knocking on the door, and health kept slamming it shut. Westbrook tore his meniscus in the 2013 playoffs after a collision with Patrick Beverley. Ibaka got hurt during the 2014 run, and Durant went down in 2015. Every time OKC looked poised for another Finals push, someone key was on the shelf.

The most painful moment came in the 2016 Western Conference Finals, when the Thunder built a 3-1 series lead over a Golden State Warriors team that had just won 73 regular-season games — and blew it, losing three straight to fall in seven. A month later, in July 2016, Durant left in free agency to join the very team that beat him.

Westbrook stuck around and won regular-season MVP in 2017, but the Thunder never got back to a deep playoff run. A decade that started with three future MVPs on one roster ended with none of them, and no championship banner to show for it.

Presti eventually rebuilt around Westbrook and Paul George before that partnership broke up too, but the real cautionary tale is still the 2012 team — the one that had Durant, Westbrook, and Harden together, beat everyone but Miami, and never got the chance to run it back.